Видео

Dear sir, excellent talk, thank you. Can RCI come to a understanding on POJK/GB??, Give to india and india allows CPEC?

Will China actively collude with Pak wrt PoK & GB in case of a war with the later

Sir, according to you what's stopping our establishment to blow up the "One China" narrative decisively - 1. Declare Tibet an independent State - or at least establish Tibet govt in exile embassy in Delhi 2. Establish full diplomatic and arms relationship with Taiwan 3. Recognise the Hong Kong democracy movement as a legitimate struggle 4. Raise Xing Jiang atrocities on Muslims issue in the UN When China is playing on front foot, why are we so shy..?

Enjoyed watching and found this a comprehensive and insightful analysis.

Hi, What about use of simulation tech in training, something like what Zen Technology is doing for defense (simulators for small and big guns, actually mounted on the gun itself).

One of the best youtube source of knowledge.

It is very interesting to know arch enemies pakistan and china are shaping up strong axis to wallop the indians 😂

Good content Sir , thank you

General shankar sir, I request you to invite brigadier devinder singh former commander 70 inf bde, for the detailed discussion on the operations in batalik sector. It would be great listening to you both on batalik ops.

After watching this video, I got even more higher respect for our Indian Army! Salute to each great warrior of the Indian Army. Thank you very much Sir for making this video and sharing all the information with us.

The present Indian Govt is aware of all the information you talked about since 2014. India has gained a lot from appointing Late Manohar Parikkar as MOD. The PM declared to ISRO and DRDO scientists and engineers that he would accept failures but wanted end results. The result is that DRDO could develop Nirbhay cruise missiles. Nirbhay ( lit. 'Fearless') is a long-range, all-weather, subsonic Cruise Missile designed and developed in India by Aeronautical Development ... Today India is a Superpower in rocket and missile technology. To fight against Pakistan and China India does not require Hyperconic missiles. There is no necessity for Hypersonic missiles if the enemy installations are within 450 to 500 km range. Pakistan Army installation. Their Sargoda Airfield is about 182 km from LAC. India can fight the war against Pakistan without the help of fighter planes. In your lecture, you did not explain the importance of Radar. Radar is like a heart and is more vulnerable to enemy attack after the invention of Anti-radiation missiles/drones. Your lecture was quite informative particularly for common people. You're doing a great job! Keep it up!

General, Sir. People forget that cost of transport by sea is a fraction than that of land. Hence CPEC was never viable. I think the ratio is 1:6. Also geography (mountains etc) is against it.

When will China learn to respect Bharat as a valued partner for mutual benefits and fair / just world ?

Pakistan is now dispensable to Middle east oil powers as the market for fossil oil is in India which it cannot afford to lose .Pak is no longer front line state as Afghan war is over. Cultural incompatibility with Chinese is overemphasized . Politics make strange bedfellows . Elite and decision makers of Pakistan are seculars and have western lifestyle with public display of Religious zeal for public consumption. CEC is in trouble for many reasons , Chinese import engineers and workers to construct the highway , Baloochistan rebels think that Pakistan is neo colonial power to extract gas and minerals . Power theft is rampant in coal electricity plants owned by Chinese corporates with loss. Pakistan is a big sink for money without return , Kleptocracy in Elite ruling class of Pakistan prevails

Importance of Malacca choke point is close to Andaman Nicobar Indian Tricity command .More than 60 percent of Chinese imports by value are transported by sea, with some 80 percent of its oil imports coming through the Malacca Strait. China interest in Pakistan is to have a CEC land route to Gwadhar in west coast of Pakistan to bypass Malacca strait . That is were the China Pakistan relationship comes . This is one sided relationship that China has to do perpetual handouts to Pakistan . China has $100 billion trade surplus with India to lose. Pakistan does not have the financial stability to conduct open warfare with India. It will indulge in low intensity non conventional proxy war with militants. India is paying back by coin supporting Balooch insurgency and making the CEC to Gwadhar port inoperative . Do not forget Chinese sat on sidelines uninvolved in Bangladesh war in 1971 . Games of chess board India is developing its own axis in littoral states surrounding China like Philippines, Japan and Vietnam. Possibility two front war is remote. All parties will have to lose in war

What is the meaning of Jaishankar and Wang Yi meeting with reference to LAC ?

Sir General PR Shanker ! The work you do is STERLING WORK to help our nation moving forward in so many ways. Thank you.

Our jawans won us kargil. Officers sitting in Delhi did nothing but force jawaans into suicide battles. I'd recommend listening to podcasts of shiv Kunal verma if anyone's interested in how Indian army higher command botched kargil op.

“ We have no eternal Allies and we do not have perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual , and those interests , it is our duty to follow ( Lord Palmerston British statesman and prime minister in speech House of Commons 1848) “observe calmly, secure our position, cope with affairs calmly, hide our capacities and bide our time, be good at maintaining a low profile, and never claim leadership.” Late Deng Xio Ping Supreme leader of Communist China responsible for Chinese rise to super power status from third world

Very interesting... Thanks

It's our privilege hear such strategic talks with them....❤

Very well said finally we dont think. Our forces should get together and watch your video.

Superb presentation

ruclips.net/video/M2-bjruii2g/видео.htmlfeature=shared China dub gaya hai

Sat sri akaal Honorable P R Shankar sahib ji as well all listeners... Jai Hind, Vandematram...

Talking about something you truly don't know about will makes you sound like a banana

Industrial total wars with no holds bar with millions of causalities on both sides is not possible between countries now . Wars with local skirmishes and wars by non state actors is going to be present and future . Advanced technological toys of war have limited utility but as deterrence . Economic warfare between countries and causing unacceptable .consequences is modern warfare . War is not substitute to peaceful political resolution

Oriana Fallaci Italian journalist interviewed late General Giap head of North Vietnam forces many decades ago Oriana Fallachi made a remark that Vietnamese did not win in any single battle with Americans General Giap replied it does not matter as the war aim is more important than a battle and Americans did not achieve their strategic aims The war now is evolved into parties inflicting unacceptable economic damage or undermining the morale ( Mutually Assured Destruction )From times immemorial It is difficult to instill fear of death in humans who are strongly motivated by religion , ideology or nationalism This makes war by lesser side possible.

Great to hear your views on the topic. Recently there is a narrative being built that Indian Army over reacted to the intrusion, it just had to wait the situation out. Your word hold more weightage than any armchair analyst.

Thank you sir for being so responsive to audience requests within the prism of security....

你的發言讓我覺得到了你的智商受到了挑戰。🤣

Jai Bharat

which rocket is more easier to shoot down or easier to detect the rocket on the air like Perception guided which is very expensive or local made cheap Hamas rocket which can be made by $2000 approx.

Israel (Jets) never miss their Target. Is it good information like 3D print their target and surrounding thats help before they shoot and may depend on technology or the person whom they send (his personal capability etc)..

War has moved to non kinetic functions but high impact across the 7 theatres of war. RSI is now one of the keys !

Thank you so much General. Most of your video helps me a lot in development, whats going on around and around the world on the India Army General point of View and not by some view points by some unknown some RUclipsr.. Again Thank You General Sir. RESPECT.

Drip / canal irrigation is targeted cheaper irrigation but is it as good as rains that is free and spread out with many unintended benefits / damages. Likewise guided / targeted missiles may not be as cost effective as pelting / raining stones that result in small explosions (in making thousand cuts in thousand places). A cost effectiveness analyses of this war mechanism is due ?

ur analysis on gaza has failed u were comparing it to the ukraine of russia, ur take on that, Worthy General

Because of you GENERAL developed curiosity on subjects you cover ... Salute to you .. Very Complex topics ..

Thank you, general sirs. __/\__

Jai Bharat Jai Hind

jai hind sir ❤

One suggestion sir, can we see a discussion on role and impact of Indian air force and indian navy during Kargil as we dont see much about them

Great discussion sir 🙏Thankyou for bringing this out

Taking pok is easy but the queston is what af6er that ? What wl.pak.n china will do ?..rhis has to be analysed..

The multidimensional aspects of China as shown by the news clips from within China show very interesting idea that the propaganda machine of CCP has been hacked by it’s own people. Thanks for a peep into this muddle.

I do not know how long our Indian leaders will let Pak stab us....inke ghar se koi nahi marta so they do not realize.... agar marta bhi hai to ye apne aap ko bhrat ratna de lete hai.....

Can you do session /s on "Unrestricted Warfare"? War is politics where blood is shed and politics is war without death.

🇮🇳Am a army brat but I don't know how army senior gernal see the situation. But one thing am sure the situation when u see as a civilian then that is totally different. And and am seeing 👀 same situation of punjab in future as manipur now. And no army and political people are focusing how missonory is changing demography same like manipur. Punjab also on the same way to becoming a new nagaland & mizoram. Same way what mayamar and china 🇨🇳 doing in that part here Pakistan and West will do the same thing in future. So my request to Army is you should tell things in strong manner to political party who are in power. And when it is necessary for the country then u should oppose them also if they are taking wrong decision which one party has done from past 60 years.

😮😮😮Sir Nagaland and in mizoram hindus 🕉 already finished Missionary ne apna kaam baraber kar diya hai . If any one got doubt then go and check in Google last servey happened in 2011 that time Christian was 87.93% toh you can guess what is the ratio is now in 2024 ab aap khud he guessing kar lo Mizoram 87.16 in 2011 nw u can guess⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️☢️ only in Manipur 41% around hindu 🕉 bachelor hai aur baaki around 40% chrishan converted.